And the battery cells themselves are half of the cost of parts. So there'd be minimal savings from redesigning the part to require fewer - or even no - fasteners or battery clips.
Ultimately, if the design even works, I want to put it out into the world. The parts are easy to acquire. There's not much soldering in the wiring - I taught myself in a weekend.
It's just the cases that a person needs... so I guess I should research print on demand solutions.
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
No prototype survives contact with production.
The solder joints must be imperfect, because the light is temperamental and will turn on and off as I move things around to close the shells. The wires are interfering with each other, physically at least. There's too much happening in the main shell.
No worries, I can iterate on the design. I need to give more room for the wires...
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
I was able to take it apart and put it back together again. Turning the center wedge 180 degrees (so the battery is "on top" when unfolded) meant for cleaner wire routes.
Tomorrow we'll charge it up, and do a bench test - see how long it can power the 12V LEDs I salvaged from a broken bike tail light.
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
That feeling when you have a working prototype.
Half of one, anyway. The LED strips are on order and will arrive later this week. Then I need to decide if I want to adhere the strips to the rims or print dozens of spoke clips to make the lights less permanent.
The weight is good - approximately one pound / half a kilogram. We'll see how it stands up in motion next weekend.
[#]biketooter #3dprinting #diy #electronics
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
I tried to get an instant quote from a print-on-demand shop for this and it says about $15 to print, and errored on shipping. Let's say $10. So at least $40 to print a pair of these, plus around $60 in supplies (plus shipping), most of which can't be found at your local hardware store.
I sure am good at designing complicated things...
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
The mark I prototype is a successful failure.
Everything worked, for a while. The battery showed a nominal 12V and could power a salvaged e-bike tail light, and later a pair of 5V LED strips wired in series.
But then something went wrong - either the BMS shorted and took a cell with it, or vice versa. I have some (hopefully) better BMS boards on order and will build the mark II when they arrive.
I've also ordered a few options for the lights and will test them head to head.
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
The two key metrics are brightness and longevity, with the latter being more important. I'd rather have modest lights that only have to be charged once in a while than overwhelming lights that have to be charged after a few hours of use.
The current contenders are:
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
Spending a lazy Saturday iterating on the mark II of the Bike Wheel Hub Battery case.
This iteration requires fewer fasteners and has a more coherent construction history in Fusion 360. It also addresses the issue of the wires pinching between the shells.
[#]biketooter #diy #electronics #3dprinting
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
I wonder if anyone has done the work to quantify the bed adhesion of #3dprinting based on total contact area - for both manual removal (a pulling force along the Z+ axis) and programmatic removal (a pushing force along the Y-axis)
Well, I've got nothing better to do today...
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
The results are .... interesting.
The model printed at an angle was much easier to remove - too easy, in fact. The supports are better adhered to the bed than they are to the model.
The model printed at an angle has a uniform outer surface. The lower edge has some defects that could be remedied with additional support fins. There may be some droop in the holes and slots but they are still within tolerances.
[#]3dprinting
=> View attached media | View attached media
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
Get in, loser, we're doing science.
One of the four options for my bike wheel lights has arrived. At least one other one should arrive today and then we can start doing bench tests and best of all, make a spreadsheet!
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
Any good experiment requires a control. The baseline is the Wheel Brightz I currently have - twenty micro LEDs powered by three AAs in a narrow plastic tube.
I measure the lights with a light meter at the center of the wheel, and measure their draw using a multimeter.
Current: 5V / 4.7 mAh
Brightness: ~5 Lux
Vibe: Ok at night, in motion.
Link - https://brightz.com/products/wheel-brightz
Price - $15 / each
[#]bikeTooter
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
First challenger is a two meter iNextStation "neon" LED tube.
Size: 12mm x 5mm x 2000mm
Power: 12V / 17 mAh
Brightness: 250 Lux
Vibe: Tron!
Link - https://a.co/d/4819hB9
Price - $10 / each
I'll probably need to 3D print some clips to attach it to the spokes with the optimum orientation. It has a 240° beam angle so it should be visible from both sides of the wheel.
If my math is right, I can get 200-250 hours of illumination on a charge.
[#]bikeTooter
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
Second lighting option in order of arrival and ease of testing is a length of LED rope light from Axel Lighting, a "marine and outdoor lighting" company.
This stuff is pricy, and a 27.5" wheel needs a little over seven feet. But it's meant for boats and Portland is wet, so I thought I'd give it a try.
Size - 3/8" x 86"
Power: 12V / 17 mAh
Brightness: 100 Lux
Vibe: Sparkles
Link: https://www.apexlighting.com/boat-lights/led-strips/led-ropelight-perfoot/
Price: $8 / ft
The lights are 1" apart, and will blur together at speed.
[#]bikeTooter
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
Pros
Cons
I maybe have to modify the plug, but it's a good option. Visible from all angles, and the spacing means the there will be a dynamic element to the lighting when in motion.
It's out of the question to use if I go down the route of building and selling full kits - a 150' spool is $1,000 and would make 10 sets, so that adds $50 to the materials cost per wheel.
Yeah, no.
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
I've got two more options to test - the EL wire is going to need some soldering so may not happen tonight. Next up is a pair of 5V COB LEDs wired in series. I expect it to be bright and thirsty.
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
Surprise, surprise. The dual 5V COB LED strips are about the same as the 12V lights.
Size: 5mm x 2000mm
Volts: 8-9V
Power: 11 mAh
Brightness: 30 Lux
Vibe: Sleek
Link: https://www.superlightingled.com/super-slim-4mm-wide-5v-cob-led-strip-320ledsm-p-5707.html
Price: $15 / pair
Pros - lights on both side of the wheel, sharp, preciae appearance.
Cons - fiddly, may not stick well, slightly more complicated wiring.
[#]bikeTooter
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
I'll solder the EL wire to the plug tomorrow - and I've ordered an option based on how well the "neon" LEDs act - a three sided diffuser that should give off more light.
And then I have to decide between the options, based on all the metrics I've listed.
I'm leaning towards the neon LEDs; so far they have been the brightest.
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
The EL wire was a bust. I don't know if I damaged it while trying to solder it, or if the inverter is bad, but I couldn't get it to light.
Given how fragile the wires are, I don't think it would have survived being in bike wheels for very long.
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
So, I have three workable options
The "neon" LED I got is single sided with a 5mmx12mm profile with a 240° beam angle. I've ordered an alternate diffuser that has a 8mm x 8mm profile with a 180° beam angle but a larger glow surface. We'll see which one looks better. The rope light is probably the most durable, but the most expensive.
Next step - build the mark II battery and road test the lights.
[#]bikeTooter
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
The second time you do something, it comes out better.
Once it's charged (and a last minute fix to the tolerances on the through mount for the DC jack is printed) I can do a wheel test and finally see the lights in motion.
[#]biketooter #diy #electronics #3dprinting
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
There's a lesson to be had here: when designing for a bike wheel, test your mockup against both wheels.
The rear wheel has a lot more stuff in the way.
Edit - turns out the front has issues, too
[#]biketooter #diy #3dprinting
=> View attached media | View attached media
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
Using some novel subtractive manufacturing techniques (I drilled a hole in the shell) I was able to connect a 2.1mm DC plug to the battery.
Unfortunately the battery case is not weather safe anymore - I'll need to plug some holes if I want to road test this.
Then I discovered that the "neon" LED tube I bought for testing purposes bends the wrong way to weave between the spokes. So I zip tied it. Maybe not the best solution but it got the job done.
[#]bikeTooter #diy #3dprinting #electronics
=> View attached media | View attached media
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
[#]bikeTooter #diy #electronics #3dprinting
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
A slow day at work gave me plenty of time to iterate on the design for the case, pushing the asymmetry I added last night by moving the inner screw point to the corner so that it overlaps the neighboring shell.
I don't think I can make this any simpler - not without switching to print-in-place fasteners. All six pieces print flat on the bed, although if I really had to, or wanted to, I could model a support structure and print them on edge, Slant 3D style.
[#]3dprinting
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
Oh hell yes!
I stumbled across American Bright LEDs, a domestic supplier of, among other things, LED rope lights. DigiKey and Mouser are among their resellers. So it would have been possible for me to get all the electronic components for this project from a single supplier!
Although I would still have gone somewhere else for the battery cells - Mouser doesn't carry 21700 cells, DigiKey charges $10 each.
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
I managed to wire up the LED rope light so it can plug into the new battery prototype and do a wheel test.
As an aside, I'm curious how this stuff is made - it looks like a series of LEDs and resistors connector by bare wire, but it's embedded in a clear PVC tube, with a center void.
At speed the LED rope lights look basically the same as the "neon" LED strip in a diffuser. The difference is the rope light has 360° visibility, while the diffuser depends on the profile.
[#]bikeTooter
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
The rope light is durable and easy to install - it's thick enough that it's a friction fit between the spokes. It's waterproof, and there are multiple domestic resellers in the US.
But its expensive, and I've had a hard time finding stores that sell it by the foot, or in 16 ft/5m lengths. And the stores that do sell it by the foot don't sell all the colors. I've found one exception but they don't list prices, so I'll have to reach out and see what they'd charge.
[#]bikeTooter
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
I'm beginning to see why nobody has ever tried something like this as a commercial product yet.
LED rope light retails for about $2 / ft in 150' spools. Assume $1 / ft wholesale. It takes about 15' for an adult bike. A waterproof DC power cable set is $2 each - assume $1 wholesale.
Add in the two pin connectors and some wires, and you have about $20 in parts. Rule of three says you sell that for $60.
That's just the lights. Don't get me started on what it costs to build a 12V battery...
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
But on the flip side, I remember hearing one of the guys at the bike shop once remark that there's no margin in the bikes themselves, but in the accessories.
I don't know that every cyclist would be willing to drop $100 a wheel on lights when there's a "good enough" option for $15 a wheel.
But as the saying goes, "don't by cheap tools". You can get a cheap cordless drill for $30 and it will last a year, or a name brand one for $300 and it will last a decade.
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
"But Ryan, your dad bought a circular saw a garage sale for $5 in the 90s and it still works!"
There's a difference between a saw used once in a while for DIY weekend projects or community theater set construction vs a saw used every day by someone in a trade.
Likewise, there's a difference between the accessories you put on a kid's bike so their helicopter parent will let them ride their bike around the block vs the accessories you put on a bike you ride to work every day.
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
Took a ride in the rain to give the latest iteration of the lights a field test. The lights stayed on and the inside of the battery stayed dry.
I need to get parts for a second battery in the front wheel, but that will have to wait until the new year.
I'm finding that PETG doesn't like to have things glued to it. Or maybe I should try to glue the foam spacers on vertically, rather than horizontally along a concave surface.
[#]biketooter #3dprinting #diy #electronics
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
I reached out to the lighting company that had SKUs in all the different colors. Turns out they don't do custom orders at this scale (15'). Also marine rope light is way over spec-ed for what I'm after. But, the sales rep did point me at a domestic supplier of RGB LED strips, so that's good.
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
I'm just a boy, standing in front of the internet, asking it why omni-directional marine grade RGB LED 3/8" rope light isn't a thing.
Best I can do is 5mm RGB LED strips in a flexible silicone diffuser tube, but I've yet to find a domesticat supplier.
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
AdaFruit has a cool, dual edge RGB LED strip that would be amazing on bike wheels, but there's two problems.
It's only 1 meter long, and it takes 5V. I need a little over 2 meters per wheel, and 12V.
As much as I wanted to avoid sticking the LEDs to the wheel rim - weaving them between the spokes is better long term - I may have no other option...
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
I just had a terrible idea.
I really, really want marine style RGB LED rope lights - bulbs spaced 1" apart in a clear tube for 360° visibility.
I may be able to just make this myself... looking at the solid color LEDs I have, it's just a bunch of LEDs in series-parallel with a resistor.
Edit: ugh, to be able to wire RGB LED bulbs in series you need the six pin variety...
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
!!!
I found a shop that sells neon RGB LEDs that meets all my requirements!
✅ 12V DC
✅ Vertical bend
✅ Narrow profile (0.4" / 10mm)
✅ IP68 waterproof
✅ Domestic supplier
Only drawback is the cost - an 8' length is $134. Each. You could get the supplies to make these for $80 plus shipping from China.
But these would be perfect for bike wheel lights!
[#]biketooter
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
As I'm continuing to spin my wheels (see what I did there?) about the options for wheel lights I had an "oh, right, duh" moment.
You don't need to do a continuous strip of lights around the rim. It's just what I want for my bike.
You could do a trio of strips along the spokes. You could do individual lights on the spokes. You could program an array of lights to animate patterns.
The important thing is that the battery will last longer than most of the off the shelf options out there.
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
@yantor3d (enjoying this thread, don’t mind me)
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from migurski@mastodon.social
@migurski Just wait until I try and so something REALLY stupid - hand made DIY RGB LED rope light!
(A proper rope light; not a mislabeled LED strip)
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from yantor3d@mas.to
@yantor3d steeples fingers
=> More informations about this toot | More toots from migurski@mastodon.social
text/geminiThis content has been proxied by September (3851b).