Toot

Written by Jocelyn Etienne on 2024-11-11 at 15:30

@mbpaz

OK, re-reading what you object to is that one should point the particular paper that "should" be cited.

There I can agree, although there'as a whole range on reviewer / author / editor behaviours and unspoken rules.

I think it's often helpful that the reviewer cites precisely some papers to point to them. Whether this sounds more or less as a request/order to cite them is the question, and the usually very superficial way the rev/author/editor discussions don't help.

=> More informations about this toot | View the thread | More toots from jocelyn_etienne@scicomm.xyz

Mentions

=> View mbpaz@mas.to profile

Tags