Toot

Written by Jocelyn Etienne on 2024-11-11 at 15:19

@mbpaz

I can give an example why I disagree: among the ideas of that prominent researcher who acted as referee, there's one very good idea that he and others supported with experiments.

Turns out there's a flaw in those, because there's an unexpected side effect that ruins the conclusions. That's been known for 15+ years, but :

• He's continued to publish on this idea and has never cited the papers showing the problem,

• no paper I've found ever cites him + the research showing the problem.

=> More informations about this toot | View the thread | More toots from jocelyn_etienne@scicomm.xyz

Mentions

=> View mbpaz@mas.to profile

Tags